October 2024 Webinar: Cost- And Resilience-Based Prioritization of Bridges for Pre-Earthquake Strengthening
Pre-quake retrofit is key to enhance the seismic resilience of road network bridge portfolios and the community as a whole. Given that the resources that are made available for this purpose are typically limited, it is important to develop a rational, efficient, yet rigorous procedure for prioritizing the bridge(s) that should be strengthened first. Current stakeholder practice tends to be mainly focusing on simply identifying the most vulnerable structures within a network, based on the data that are gathered by means of regular maintenance schemes, sometimes further convoluting the regional or site-specific hazard and the associated bridge-dependent seismic risk. In this paper, a resilience-based decision-making framework is presented, for further considering the direct and indirect losses in prioritizing those bridges for which a potential failure may have a disproportional impact at a road network level. A large-scale computational framework is introduced and employed in three consecutive steps. First, seismic hazard, vulnerability, exposure and consequence of failure in the form of diverted traffic flow are duly quantified and accounted for probabilistically, in order to estimate the direct and indirect cost of earthquake scenarios for the network “as-built” (i.e., without any pre-earthquake retrofit). Next, alternative scenarios of bridge strengthening are explored, and the above loss quantities are updated. Finally, a set of resilience-based indicators are introduced to calculate the cost-benefit of each individual strengthening scheme, thus identifying the bridges whose structural upgrade has the highest relative (cost-benefit) impact on the resilience on the network. The applicability of the framework is presented for the case of a realistic road network in a highly seismic region. The results highlight that conventional risk-based bridge retrofit prioritization may well disregard, highly efficient, low-cost retrofit options that can significantly enhance the resilience of the entire network.
Watch now